Rutherford Elementary
- Enrollment
- 573
- Students per teacher
- 17.4
115 Rutherford Rd, Stillwater, MN 55082
(651) 351-6400





Privacy, space and an opportunity for multigenerational living come together in this impeccably maintained 4,875-square-foot home set on 2.6 beautifully wooded acres. Situated on a private corner lot just minutes from Stillwater and Lake Elmo, this distinctive home offers two primary suites with one on the main level and a second primary suite as well as a junior suite upstairs. Beautiful hardwood floors, rich architectural details and abundant windows create warmth and character throughout, with multiple gathering spaces designed for both everyday living and entertaining. The kitchen and informal dining area are beautifully connected to the living room by a dramatic two-sided fireplace, creating a warm and inviting focal point for the main living spaces. The cedar-lined sunroom overlooks the peaceful backyard and offers a wonderful place to enjoy a cup of coffee and the changing seasons! The lower level adds even more flexibility with a family room for movies and recreation room for games and fun - plus a sauna and workout room! Outside, expansive decking, a hot tub and beautifully landscaped grounds create a private retreat surrounded by mature trees. The four-car garage provides exceptional storage including space for a boat to enjoy the nearby St. Croix River. A rare opportunity to enjoy the privacy and serenity of an estate-like setting with the convenience of being close to everything Stillwater and Lake Elmo have to offer. And seller is offering $12,000 in seller paid closing costs to help with a rate buydown!
In this neighborhood, homes were most commonly built in 2010-2019, about 56% of occupied homes are owner-occupied, and the average commute is 25 minutes.
$725,500
Higher than the Twin Cities metro
The midpoint of estimated values for owner-occupied homes.
$5,694/yr
Higher than the Twin Cities metro
The midpoint of annual property taxes paid by homeowners.
$3,297/mo
Higher than the Twin Cities metro
Median monthly housing costs for owners with a mortgage.
$970/mo
Higher than the Twin Cities metro
Median monthly housing costs for owners without a mortgage.
$2,408/mo
Higher than the Twin Cities metro
The midpoint of monthly gross rent, including utilities.
56%
Lower than Twin Cities metro overall
The share of occupied homes lived in by their owners.
2004
Newer than the Twin Cities metro
The midpoint of years when homes in the area were built.
The share of homes built during each period.
The share of housing units in each building type.
25 min
Similar to the Twin Cities metro
The average one-way travel time to work for commuters.
The share of workers using each listed way to get to work.
91%
Similar to Twin Cities metro overall
The share of households with a broadband internet subscription.
Stillwater Area Public Schools
This home is in the Rutherford Elementary, Stillwater Middle School and Stillwater Area High School attendance areas of Stillwater Area Public Schools.
115 Rutherford Rd, Stillwater, MN 55082
(651) 351-6400523 Marsh St W, Stillwater, MN 55082
(651) 351-69055701 Stillwater Blvd N, Stillwater, MN 55082
(651) 351-804013380 51st Street Court N in Stillwater, MN, is listed at $1,200,000 as of Nov 19, 2026 ($246 per finished square foot and 51 days on market).
Stillwater Area Public Schools. It is in the attendance areas for Rutherford Elementary (grades K-5, 2.5 mi), Stillwater Middle School (grades 6-8, 1.8 mi) and Stillwater Area High School (grades 9-12, 0.8 mi), according to Minnesota Department of Education 2025-26 boundaries. Assignments can change, so confirm enrollment with the district.
Property taxes are $7,887 for 2026, or $7,890 including special assessments. No special assessments are pending.
No. The listing shows no homeowners association fee.
It has a private well and a private septic system. Minnesota requires a septic disclosure, and many lenders and buyers order a compliance inspection.
The average one-way commute for the surrounding area is 25 minutes, compared with 24 minutes for the Twin Cities metro. About 68% of workers drive alone. Source: U.S. Census Bureau, American Community Survey 2020-2024 5-year estimates for the surrounding census tract.
Call Pederson Realty anytime at 612-356-2121 to ask about this home, schedule a showing, or be connected to an agent. You can also contact the agent shown on this page or use the Tour in Person button. We can usually set up a showing within a day.